![]() |
|
Spaces home A Golfing MichiganderPhotosProfileFriends | ![]() |
|
March 07 Forest DunesAfter reading the latest version of Great Lakes Golf (March/April), panic set in. Why? The headline story was Forest Dunes 2.0; Northern Michigan's Landmark Course Finds New Purpose. So? Well, they "discovered the public model wasn't the best fit" and they intend to make the course/club private. Apparently, not many people were "beat[ing] a path to its door". Oops, guess that would include me. Even though it has been high on my must-play list since opening in 2002, I just never made it there. I've balked a bit at the $125 greens fee, but it is possible to play in off hours for less. Well, now if they are going private, I better hurry up there before it's completely inaccessible. An additional panic boost came because I've already missed an opportunity to play on another course that is now private. True North. They were public (semi-private, really) for a while. I dilly-dallied going there for the longest time and now I can't, in all likelihood, ever. It makes me ill to look at these photographs and not be able to play the course: [twoguyswhogolf] [fore.tv] [Michigan Golf] [wwjtv] Not good planning on my part, so don't miss out on your chance either. The Forest Dunes course looks beautiful. It is especially compelling now that we're going through one of the snowiest winters on record. May can't get here any sooner. March 04 Selfridge Air National Guard BaseAlright, this is bordering on ridiculous. Another golf course is on the chopping block. This time it's the course at Selfridge. This, according to the Selfridge MWR (Morale, Welfare, & Recreation) anyway. They write, "The Golf Course is subject to the BRAC closure, and will be closing 2 September 08." Bummer. At least I had the priviledge of playing the course once. This was when I played with the Greater Macomb Area Golf Association (an amateur golf organization no longer in the GAM Allied Associations list). Back in 1996. Yikes.
What a shame though. The MWR has this to say about the course: "The Selfridge Golf Course was originally established in the late 1940s and is situated at the southeast end of the Selfridge Air National Guard Base flight line. A 2.6 million dollar project in October 1997 resulted in an improved par 72, PGA-sanctioned course complete with large undulating greens, well-drained sand traps, and challenging new hole layouts. The Driving Range features 2 tiers with ample tee space, 5 artificial mats, and 3 large practice target greens along with a practice sand trap. Adjacent to the clubhouse is an 8000 square foot putting green surface with many levels, mounds, and rolls to challenge all players, beginner to pro!"
Maybe someone will buy the place. March 02 Sugar Loaf ResortNot that I'm morbid about these things, but it looks like Sugar Loaf Resort near Traverse City is up for sale (closed?) While doing some casual browsing today, I came across the Leelanau News Blog at leelanau.com which has been discussing this very topic. It would appear that the resort is not even open to the public right now and hasn't been for a couple years or more. No golf (and not just because it is winter) and no skiing. Another (golf course) victim of this situation appears to be the Arnold Palmer King's Challenge golf course. That may be old news, however, as the web site for that course is still operational. That's a bit of relief as that course is unique and beautiful. Post your comments here if you know more about this situation. February 02 Top 10 Michigan Courses?The Winter issue of Michigan Golfer (pdf) has a bunch of top 10 lists on a range of different golf things. One of them is a list from Golfweek of the top 10 courses in Michigan. Now, presumably, these are intentionally just public courses, otherwise, you know, Oakland Hills South would be on the list and it isn't.
I do like these kind of lists and although they are always subjective, I have to pick on a couple of their choices. Here is the list (no particular order?): Arcadia Bluffs Wilderness Valley - Valley Course Bay Harbor - Links Course Bay Harbor - Quarry Course Gailes Treetops Signature Black Lake [1] Surely they meant the Black Forest course and not the older Valley Course. Right? [2] Links and Quarry are both 9 holers. Shouldn't they be lumped together as one entry in the list of 10. As it stands, this is actually a top 9 list. [3] The Signature course at Treetops? I would think that the Jones Masterpiece (or maybe even the Fazio) is the better of the two. [4] What about some of these as a candidate for the missing 10th course? Shepherd's Hollow, The Hills at Boyne Highlands, The Bear at GTRV, Elk Ridge, The Majestic at Lake Walden, Legend or Cedar River at Shanty Creek, ... I could go on... October 03 Course Closure in FrankfortI just learned that there is another Michigan golf course that is closed for business. Frankfort Golf Club. Located on the Lake Michigan side of Crystal Lake, it was a 9 hole course that opened in 1928. Judging by the photo of the old clubhouse, it would appear that business has been slow and the lure of an offer from a developer was too irresistible. That's pure speculation on my part though.
The list of course closures in the state is piling up. Hate to see 'em go.
June 10 Greywalls RevisitedA while back I wrote about the new golf course designed by Mike DeVries in Marquette. It received a lot of acclaim then and seems to be continuing with that even now. While browsing through some old Firefox bookmarks, I happened across the golf course design web site GolfClubAtlas.com. If you enjoy golf course architecture even a little bit you must have seen this web site by now. Always on the lookout for favorable comments on Michigan golf courses, I was pleased to see a feature article on Greywalls on their web site. The best part are all the excellent photographs of the course. Really makes me want to play there now. Have to manage the private club status and 10-some hour drive to get there though.
Other Michigan courses reviewed on that web site include (I might be repeating myself here):
Pretty respectable showing for the state I think. February 06 Square Club FollyApparently, a number of manufacturers are coming out with a new style of golf club head. Square. I have one word for 'em: hideous. And I do not care if the geometry is more suitable for hitting the ball further or not. Just like their fellow overbloated predecessors, I can't stand to look at them while addressing the ball. Maybe it is just a matter of adaptation -- I'd get used to it after a while until it becomes the new norm. There is only one problem -- they cost too much.
The prices of clubs skyrocketed in the 90s or so. I remember when a driver was in the $100 range or so, then all of a sudden the next increment took 'em to $300, $400, $500. Was it the new materials? Titanium. Graphite. Inflation?
Maybe a quick comparison would help. What else can you buy in the $400 range? How about a bandsaw? Jet sells a modest 14" model for that price.
Now, what is it about a golf club that even remotely compares to the materials, labor costs, shipping constraints, etc. of producing a piece of machinery like this? Maybe it is because they don't sell that many, so they are more expensive? Unlikely. How many people do you know that would buy a bandsaw vs. a driver? It has to be that they price those clubs like that because they can. All those people who have such tremendous amounts of disposable income, the piles of it are practically pushing them out of their homes, are just so desperate that they just gotta have that latest golf club, they'll pay anything. Why can't people take a stand and just say, no, that's too much. I'd rather do without than pay that. It would work with cable service, internet service, cell phone service, home construction and supplies (esp. kitchen cabinetry), etc. But don't get me started on that stuff.
Related Articles:
December 20 Celebrity GolfersThe very first time I ever swung a golf club, it was during gym glass in junior high school when the instructor must have wanted us to try some other sport besides basketball, baseball, and tag football. A good idea in principle, I suppose, but lacking in the implementation. There were no golf courses within 20 miles of the school, only a handful of beater clubs available, and no golf balls. Not even those plastic practice balls. What's the next best thing though? Why, pine cones, of course.
So, we spent one hour or less of one day hitting pine cones all of 20 feet or so. During this time, the football players in the class would have nothing to do with this sissy sport and enjoyed themselves snickering at those less close-minded folks who were willing to try something, even if only once. It wasn't until college some years later before I picked up a club again (it was a permanent addiction from that point on).
What made me think of this was the article that Golf Digest published this month entitled the "Top 100 in Music". It's a list of musicians who play golf ranked by their USGA Handicap Index. I can imagine that a number of people on this list probably used to sneer at the sport in much the same way that the football player types I knew did. Can you picture these guys on a golf course and lovin' it? Eddie Van Halen, Alice Cooper, Snoop Dogg, Meat Loaf, Tommy Lee, and Kid Rock.
A few years after my initial foray into the sport, I ran into one of those guys ... on the golf course. Thought that was funny ironic. December 12 Putting courseThere are some nice putting greens at some of the courses in Michigan and there are some nice par 3 courses too, but how many putting courses can you claim to have played? If you are like me, none. Oh, Pirate's Cove doesn't count.
So, here is your chance to give one a try. I'll have to finagle a trip somehow and head up to Bucks Run in Mount Pleasant to try theirs. Looks very cool. Probably a very busy place on a warm summer evening. December 10 Easiest Holes IIContinuing with the series, here is another hole for the list.
#14, Portage Lake Golf Club, Michigan Technological University, 115-112-97 yars, par 3, handicap 18.
It might normally be enough to decide that any par 3 this short should be on a list of easy holes. However, just looking at this shortie from the tee won't lead you to think that. So, as long as you can keep your wits about you, a par or less should be well within reach.
Some of the things that can confound your par efforts here include-
Given those things though, I've found that my scores over the years on this hole have been pretty decent in spite of my beginner status for most of 'em. Lotsa pars, in other words. USGA Tournaments in MILooking over the recaps of the USGA championship season in the members publication Inside the USGA, I see that another year passes without a tournament in Michigan. It got me to wondering when the next one will be held here. I kind of squandered the opportunity to see the APL when it came to The Orchards in 2002. I don't want that to happen next time.
The USGA Championships page on their website lists future competitions. It only shows the next two years, but that's enough for me to realize that it's going to be a while before an amateur event comes to the State. Sure, we've got some PGA events on horizon, but I'd like to see something a little less popular. When I attended a practice round of the Ryder Cup in 2004, there was, like, a trillion people there. Hard to see much of anything. The Ryder Cup was bad too because there were only a few groups actually playing. But, it was still very cool being there - something I need to do more often. It's worth going even if it is just for the opportunity to walk on these courses that you would otherwise be arrested for being on. Unless you're lucky enough to know a member or have some rare opportunity arise.
November 30 Out of touchWow. The last blog entry here was in April - not long before I went on a sabbatical from golf. My last round was in May .. well, ok, I did play 13 holes in October. Having loved and played this sport since 1980, this is the longest stretch of time in which I have quit playing like this. Even the typical forced winter break is only a few months. Four or so. With 30 degree temps coming after today, there'll be even more time off. I needed the mental break - it's not hard for this sport to lose it's appeal sometimes. April 05 HilltopManaged to make it out for some golf for the first time in 2006. It's been a long wait since early November when I was last able to play. Nice to be out there in spite of the fact that the courses are a little muddy and just plain blah after the long winter. Fall is a much nicer time to play in the off season.
Went to Hilltop Golf Course both last week and this for some 9-hole practice. The course is not busy at all which makes it conducive for hitting 2-3 balls on each hole. The course has really greened up in just 7 days. Gets me looking at my lawn too - have to mow the darn thing before you know it.
I hear that the former owners of the course (American Golf Corporation) have parted ways and it is now run by Plymouth Twp. again. The guy in the pro shop said that AGC has not taken very good care of the course in the last couple of years and they are intending on returning the course to its former glory. That will be nice because this is kind of a sleeper golf course. The greens here are almost unfairly fast and devilishly contoured. What you think might be a 6" break turns out to be more like 6 feet. Everyone complains about the greens, but they all come hurrying back to try them again.
Currently, there are 5 courses in Michigan (Detroit area only) owned by American Golf Corporation. They have done some good things for these courses, including Hilltop when they first took it over. I was surprised to see how poorly they handled it recently. Not making enough money for them perhaps. Anyway, here are those five:
February 15 Metal Medal ResortsGolf Magazine is out with another list. This time it is their Gold and Silver Medal resorts. They base them on the golf (first of course), service, amenities, and overall luxury of the experience.
Here is the Michigan contingent:
Gold Medal
<conspicuously empty> Silver Medal
. Boyne Highlands Harbor Springs . The Inn at Bay Harbor
Bay Harbor . Shanty Creek Resort & Club
Bellaire . Treetops Resort
Gaylord Not bad for a Mid-Western State. As you can imagine, most of the resorts are found in the warm weather States. You know, Hawaii, California, Florida. Getting four on the list is not bad for a State that is under a pile of snow for several months.
Noticeably absent from the list is another fine resort - Garland. I'll have to send Golf an eMail and find out what it was about that excellent resort that they did not like. This should be interesting. Not enough ad dollars? Too far into the boonies perhaps.
Let me add a few of my own using no particular evaluation properties other than impulse (and personal experience with). These would not make their list but we all can't be spoiled rich snobs who can only go to a Gold Medal resort now can we? :)
. Boyne Mountain
. Garland . Grand Traverse Resort and Spa . Crystal Mountain . Double JJ Ranch & Golf Resort . Beaver Creek Resort . Drummond Island Resort . Manistee National . Sugar Loaf There are plenty more, but I'll stop there.
January 24 GolfClubAtlasIf you are into golf course architecture, and who wouldn't a little bit if you love the sport, there is a good website I like to read every now and then - GolfClubAtlas.com. It has good articles and forums whose members are well versed on the topic. And, of course, I always seek out the Michigan golf courses featured there. Unfortunately, the two they have are both private and very exclusive: Lost Dunes (a Tom Doak) and Crystal Downs (Perry Maxwell/Alister MacKenzie course).
Oh, wait a minit, there is a public course in Michigan on their list: High Pointe (another Tom Doak). This one I have played. It contains a contrasting pair of nines - the front is a "links" style very much out in the open, while the back nine is in the style of Northern Michigan all the way. Nice and hilly and wooded. Just a wonderful place to play. And the best part? They allow walking. The other public golf course he did in Michigan allows walking too - Black Forest. Makes me wonder if it is one of his requirements when buildling a course. January 16 Birch FallsThere is a new golf course being built in Northern Michigan that has caught my attention since it is in an area that I used to know. For a while there they had a web site which detailed the course and the community being built around it. I drove by there recently, but it is hard to tell how much progress they made last summer, so I made a return visit to their web site, and lo and behold, it is no longer up. Reading the Google-cached version, the home page used to read:
Makes me wonder if development has stopped. Great Lakes Golf mentioned it in a recent online article as part of a list of courses that "debut in 2005". Here were the details:
Add a comment if you know more about this. January 04 Featured Course IVLet the following accolades speak for the course-
In summary, put this on your must play list.
December 27 Featured Course IIITreetops - Jones Masterpiece Masterpiece is a good name for this golf course. It is cut through the forest that grew over the glacier carved valleys in the Pigeon River area. Easily one of the best courses I've ever played. Watch it though, it is brutally tough. Choose your set of tees carefully. I have a hole-by-hole description of the course from the pages of an old website I used to maintain. Here it is...
December 26 Stroke of GeniusJust a few days ago I happened to watch the movie Bobby Jones: Stroke of Genius on DVD (library rental). Having a history of bad sports/golf movies to disappoint me, my expectations for this one were a bit low. What a pleasant surprise to find out that this was actually a very well done movie. It covered his life from youth through his competitive years of golfing nicely. I would recommend this movie to any golfing fan.
See how it rates compared to other golf movies I have seen:
* Caddyshack - the King of golf movies. Absolutely hilarious and true to golf afficianados everywhere. It is the standard by which any other golf comedy is done. Everything else on my list is a distant second.
* Tin Cup - well done movie with both comedy and serious golf. Cameos add to the class of the movie.
* Bobby Jones: Stoke of Genius - this could easily be in 2nd place, but I like the humor in Tin Cup.
* Happy Gilmore - had the potential to be an awful movie, but it was excellent. Bob Barker appearance was outstanding.
* The Legend of Bagger Vance - pretty good - nothing great though. Didn't dislike it. How's that for a non-commital review?
* Dead Solid Perfect - Randy Quaid plays a lowly pro. Unremarkable movie. * Follow the Sun - Ben Hogan movie starring Glenn Ford. Rather corny and not very well done.
* Caddyshack II - horrible, horrible, horrible. All traces of the existence of this terrible movie should be eradicated from this universe.
--
Here are some I have not seen:
* The Greatest Game Ever Played - movie about Francis Ouimet. Hopefully it will be good. The story behind it sure is.
* A Gentlemen's Game - has some potential.
Any I missed?
December 22 Baypointe Country ClubAs I reported in an earlier posting, one of the many courses closing here in SE MI includes the private course Bay Pointe in West Bloomfield. Rumor has it that before the course actually closes for good it will be open to the public. This is good news - I am always looking for an opportunity to play these (to whatever degree) exclusive places. I actually have played this course once. A longtime golfing buddy sent them a letter some time ago asking for permission to play and they obliged. Ok, so it was off season (April), it was still the first private course that we were able to play. It remains to be seen if they will open to the public or not, but don't miss out on the chance if it is true. |
|
|